A roofer’s reference list is a sales document. The contractor picked those names, called them first, and left off anyone who might say something awkward. That does not make the list worthless, but it does mean a reference call is a starting point rather than a verdict. This guide covers what to ask the references you are handed, how to get addresses the contractor did not choose, and the four public records that answer the questions a happy customer honestly cannot. It is written for Greater Cincinnati, where the answer to “is this company registered?” changes depending on which side of a municipal line your house sits on.
First, drop the question about a state license
The most common reference-call question is some version of “were they licensed?” In Ohio, that question has no useful answer for a roof. The Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board licenses five trades: electrical, heating ventilating and air conditioning, plumbing, hydronics and refrigeration. Roofing is not among them, and neither is general contracting. There is no state roofing license to hold, no state board to call, and a past customer who tells you the crew was “state licensed” is repeating something they were told.
What does exist is local registration, insurance coverage you can verify yourself, and manufacturer certification you can confirm with the manufacturer. Those are the checks worth making, and none of them depend on who answers the phone.
Four records to check before you dial
Budget about twenty minutes. Do this before the reference calls, because what you find changes the questions you ask.
1. City registration, if the work is inside Cincinnati
Cincinnati Municipal Code Chapter 1106 requires every contractor working inside the city limits to hold a current contractor registration, renewed annually, and the city will not issue a building permit until the contractors on the job are registered. Registration runs $125 plus surcharges, a total of $131.25 a year. You can check any company yourself through the county’s Find A Registered Contractor lookup, or call the Contractor Registration Section at 513-352-3271 and choose option one.
This is where the municipal line matters. If your house is in Oakley, the city rule applies to your roof. If you are in Blue Ash, Montgomery, Mason, Indian Hill or Milford, you are in a separate municipality with its own building department, and West Chester sits in Butler County entirely. Registration in Cincinnati says nothing about standing in Mason, so ask your own building department what they require and whether the company is on their list.
2. Workers’ compensation coverage
Ohio’s Bureau of Workers’ Compensation publishes an employer lookup that will confirm whether a company carries active coverage. It takes a minute and it is the single check most homeowners skip. Do the same with general liability: ask for the certificate of insurance and then call the agent or carrier printed on it rather than trusting a PDF forwarded from the salesperson’s phone. A certificate is a snapshot of one day, and the number on it is the fastest way to find out whether the policy is still in force.
3. Permit history, and what it will not show you
Hamilton County’s CAGIS records search will pull permits by address, which lets you check what a contractor actually filed on a job they are pointing you toward. There is an important caveat for roofs. Under the city’s residential permit guide, roof coverings of no more than two layers are exempt from a building permit on one to three family dwellings, along with siding, like-for-like window replacement, and gutters and downspouts. An empty permit record therefore proves nothing about a reroof inside the city. Use the search for additions, structural work and anything that changed the footprint, and treat its silence on a roof as meaningless rather than suspicious.
One exception worth knowing: if the property is locally designated as historic, a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Urban Conservator is required before the work starts, regardless of whether a building permit is. That office is reachable at 513-352-4848.
4. The Attorney General’s office
On October 14, 2026, Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson filed suit against two home improvement companies. One, a Lorain County restoration firm, is accused of taking roughly $140,000 from nine customers for roofing, siding and gutter projects that were never finished. The other, a central Ohio metal roofing company, is accused of substandard work and of accepting payment for a roof it never started, with five consumers reporting combined losses of more than $60,000. Neither is a Cincinnati company, but both describe the pattern precisely: money up front, work that stalls, a phone that stops being answered. The consumer complaint line is 1-800-282-0515.
Five questions worth asking a reference
Most reference-call lists are built from questions that only have one socially acceptable answer. “Were you satisfied?” gets you a yes. These five are harder to answer politely without telling you something.
“What exactly did they do, and when?”
You want the scope and the date before anything else. A full tear-off on a 1960s ranch in Milford tells you nothing about how the company handles a slate repair, and a reference from this spring tells you about the crew but nothing about how the roof held up. Ask for a mix: at least one job like yours, and at least one that is two to five years old. If every name on the list is from the last ninety days, you are looking at a storm run rather than a track record.
“What did the final invoice say next to the estimate?”
Ask for the two numbers and the reason for the gap. A change order is not a red flag by itself, since nobody can see the decking through the shingles. What you are testing is whether the homeowner knew the number was moving before it moved. If you want a sanity check against the range for your own house, our page on roof replacement cost in Cincinnati is a better reference point than a national average.
“What happened when they tore off and found bad decking?”
This is the most useful question on the list, because almost every job hits some version of it. You are listening for a process: the crew stopped, showed the homeowner the plywood, quoted the per-sheet price that was already in the contract, and carried on. The answer you do not want is a number that appeared for the first time on the final bill.
“Who was actually on your roof?”
Ask whether the crew worked for the company or for a subcontractor, whether the same people were there all three days, and whether the salesperson who sold the job ever came back. Subcontracting is normal and not a problem on its own. Not knowing it was happening is.
“What happened in the first year?”
Callbacks are where a roofing company’s character shows. Ask whether anything leaked, how long the return visit took to schedule, and whether the warranty was ever registered with the manufacturer. That last one catches a lot of people, because manufacturer coverage often depends on paperwork the contractor was supposed to file. Our explanation of the GAF system warranty walks through what registration covers and what it does not.
Then close with the question that actually gets a complaint out of a satisfied customer: “what would you do differently?” Almost nobody answers “nothing.”
Read the list itself, not just the people on it
Before you call anyone, look at the shape of what you were given. Five addresses within one subdivision and one month is a storm run. An all-new-construction list from a company bidding on your 1958 house is the wrong portfolio. A reference who cannot name the crew lead probably spoke to the salesperson and nobody else. And a supplier is not a customer: lumber yards and distributors will confirm that a company pays its bills, which is useful, but it is not evidence about workmanship, and the two get quietly blended on a lot of reference sheets.
Then ask for something the contractor did not prepare. Request two addresses of completed jobs three or more years old within ten miles, and go drive past them. From the street you can see whether the ridge line is straight, whether the shingle courses run level above the garage, whether the valleys are cut cleanly, and whether there is gutter apron at the eaves. A roof that still looks right after three Ohio Valley winters is better evidence than any phone call, and our project gallery and customer testimonials are there for the same reason: addresses and names you can check.
If they knocked on your door after a storm
After the severe weather that moved through Hamilton County this past August, door-to-door roofing solicitation across Greater Cincinnati picked up sharply, and it has not stopped. The reference-call advice above still applies, but there is a legal protection worth knowing about first.
Under Ohio’s Home Solicitation Sales Act, a sale of $25 or more made at your home carries a cooling-off period: you have until midnight of the third business day to cancel. The seller has to give you a written notice of cancellation form and a copy of the signed agreement, must not begin the work until that period has run, and must refund you within ten days of receiving your cancellation. If a salesperson standing in your driveway wants a signature today and work started tomorrow, those two things are in tension, and that is worth saying out loud.
None of this is legal or insurance advice, and terms change. Confirm current requirements with the Attorney General’s office, your own attorney or your carrier before relying on them. If the damage is storm related, our guides to storm damage and insurance claims and the roof insurance claim process cover how the claim and the contractor decision fit together. For everything that belongs in the contract itself, from payment schedule to cleanup terms, work through our Cincinnati roofing project checklist before you sign anything.
What a reference can never tell you
A past customer can tell you how a company behaved on one roof. They cannot tell you whether the company is registered where you live, whether its coverage is still active this month, or whether its manufacturer certification is current. Certification in particular is worth verifying at the source rather than through a testimonial, because it is the basis for the stronger system warranties; our GAF System Plus certification page explains what the designation requires. Use the records for the facts, use the references for the behavior, and treat any gap between the two as the answer.
If you are putting together a shortlist in Oakley, Blue Ash, Montgomery, Mason, Milford, Indian Hill or West Chester and want a reference list with addresses on it, call Sterling Exteriors at (513) 685-8055 and ask for jobs in your neighborhood from three years ago, not three weeks ago.